Among the three-the-ideal-compromise-in-between-affordability-and-performance options are the Mazdaspeed6, Mazdaspeed3, and the Subaru Impreza. What each model gives is unique: either all-wheel drive capability, turbochargers, or even rally-inspired handling. In the United States, these cars will be adored for their driving thrills without the whopping prices usually tagged with high-performance rigs. But given such similar specs and features, how do you decide which is best for your needs?
The Mazdaspeed6 has often been regarded as that sleeper sedan, bringing practical daily use and some serious horsepower under the hood. Conversely, the Mazdaspeed3 is a hot hatch for those seeking agility in control and turbocharged fun without needing all-wheel drive. It packs a punch but has quirks, like front-wheel-drive torque steer. Lastly, the Subaru Impreza WRX and STI models are a cut above all the rest. Their all-weather prowess and rally heritage lend unbeatable reliability and handling in tricky conditions. Those who experience snow or rain daily in U.S. climes will choose one of these models.
Which one of the three options do you choose? If you want a car to overcome ice-laden winter roads, if you need a high-performance vehicle that does not lose some of its practicality, or something in between, here are the strengths and weaknesses of each car. Knowing what makes them different will help you identify the model that best fits your lifestyle, driving habits, and budget.
Let’s examine every aspect of performance, practicality, and pros and cons for each vehicle. Ultimately, you should have an excellent sense of which is best for your specific needs—daily commuting, weekend joy rides, or just getting you where you want to be, rain, shine, sleet, or snow.
1. Mazdaspeed6: The Under-the-Radar Sport Sedan
Quick Review:
- Years made: 2006-2007
- Engine: 2.3L turbocharged 4-cylinder
- Horsepower: 274 hp
- Drive Type: All-Wheel Drive (AWD)
- Transmission: 6-speed manual
The Mazdaspeed6 tried to mold a sleeper sports sedan for Mazda, and they fulfilled it. The turbocharged 2.3L power plant with an all-wheel drive system draws a rather indifferent line regarding having both speed and practicality simultaneously. It is just a beefed-up version of the Mazda6 sedan but with more horsepower, a rigid suspension, and an aggressive body kit.
Performance: The Mazdaspeed6 was built to handle much more power with composure on the road. But just like any car, there is a need to be watchful for signs of engine damage, which often comes in subtle but quite critical detection to prevent costly repairs. AWD tightly grips the road, so once you get into quick acceleration and turn-in maneuvers, you can exercise control over the vehicle. That makes for excellent all-weather conditions, particularly important in the U.S. when dealing with snow or rain.
It does have some turbo lag in that it has to wait a tiny instant for the turbo to engage after mashing the gas pedal. But after the turbo kicks in, the Mazdaspeed6 feels punchy and quick. Driving on highways and mountain roads is a complete blast, where you think power is balanced with handling.
Interior & Practicality: The Mazdaspeed6’s best part is its pretty standard-looking sedan that hides all the performance. It’s big enough for five passengers, with room and a decent-sized trunk, so it’s perfect for people who need a daily driver with some pep.
However, as a performance car, it will most likely not be fuel efficient compared to a regular sedan. It will also need regular maintenance, mainly on the turbocharger and the AWD system, because if they are not taken good care of, they tend to cost quite a penny.
Pros
- AWD would mean excellent grip and stability
- The turbocharged engine is potent
- A sedan design would make it suitable for daily driving
Cons
- The low production will make it hard to find in the market
- Maintenance expenses will be higher, mainly concerning the AWD system.
- Some turbo lag is infuriating.
2. Mazdaspeed3: The Hot Hatch Everyone Spits About
Quick Review:
- Years: 2007-2013
- Engine: 2.3L turbocharged 4-cylinder
- Horsepower: 263 hp
- Drive Type: Front-Wheel Drive
- Transmission: 6-speed manual
If you enjoy hatchbacks, then the Mazdaspeed3 should have caught your eye. Based on the amazing Mazda3, this hot hatch variant has a turbocharged engine and front-wheel drive, making it one of the most exciting and accessible hot hatches of its time.
Performance: Mazdaspeed3 is a front-wheel drive, which isn’t anywhere near the grip of the AWD Mazdaspeed6, but it’s still a hammer. This hatchback can pick up the pace nicely with its 263 horsepower and packs well to keep you moving quickly. However, you could find torque steer in this car because it’s a front-wheel-drive configuration, which can pull you toward one side when accelerating seriously.
Sure enough, though, the Mazdaspeed3’s rather spry handling makes it a joy to drive through tighter stretches of city streets or twisty roads where you can feel the car’s agility. Such all comes at a price of a little stiff ride as the suspension is highly tuned for its performance rather than comfort.
Although the Mazdaspeed3 is certainly a thrill, it’s not built to handle heavy loads compared to SUVs or trucks. But if you love to push your vehicle to the limit, you might wonder about the best overland vehicles.
Interior & Utility: Hatchbacks are about versatility, and the Mazdaspeed3 doesn’t disappoint. The rear seats fold down to give you plenty of cargo space, perfect for a weekend getaway or grocery runs. It has a rather driver-focused interior with sporty seats that hold you in place during spirited driving.
Like the Mazdaspeed6, the Mazdaspeed3’s fuel economy could be better, mainly if you use your turbo often. As a performance car, the tires, brakes, and suspension components will wear out sooner than on a regular Mazda3.
Pros
- It has a reasonable price for another hot hatch
- Rip-roaring, turbocharged solid engine
- Versatile hatch design with decent space in the back for luggage
Cons
- Front-wheel drive means there will be torque steer when you’re accelerating hard
- The suspension system rides a bit stiffer than the standard Mazda3.
- Poor Fuel Economy
3. Subaru Impreza: The All-Weather Warrior
Quick Review:
- Available from: 1992-Present. In reality, performance models are primarily the WRX and STI.
- Engine(s): Numerous options ranging from a 2.0L to a 2.5L turbocharged in the performance models
- Horsepower: between 152 and 310 hp. Depending on the model and year
- Drive Type: AWD
- Transmission: 5-speed manual, CVT, and 6-speed manual on the WRX/STI
The Subaru Impreza remains one of the legends of the rally world, not least in its variants like WRX and STI. Its fame has tagged it as the most reliable and spirited vehicle that can easily withstand harsh weather conditions. If you are a person who stays in the wintry environment of your country, then Impreza is your option.
Performance: In the performance area, the WRX and STI models come alive in the Subaru Impreza. WRX models have turbocharged engines with a quick, punchy drive. The WRX is suitable for those who want a sporty drive without blowing all of their budget on a high-performance model, while the STI would be the ultimate buy if one wants that little bit of extra power and handled tight. For those who love testing the limits of their car, the Subaru Impreza WRX/STI offers plenty of power, but you’ll need a place to test the car’s max speed to explore its full capabilities safely.
The Impreza’s AWD system is one of the top-notch systems in the business, delivering excellent traction on snowy roads or dry pavement. With rally heritage, bet on it; it’s built to pass through potholes and beaten paths easily.
Interior & Practicality: One of the bright spots of the Impreza is its practicality. While performance models such as WRX and STI leave a little less room, the regular Impreza is, on the other hand, a roomy compact car. Both front and rear passengers fit inside, and their trunk space is also okay for the class. The interior is quite simple but functional, and the controls are also easy to use. It also has a good infotainment system.
Fuel economy is respectable for the base Impreza but notches down some with the WRX and STI, especially if you drive them as you stole them. Subaru’s reputation is for building a historically reliable vehicle, but the same is true for any performance car: regular maintenance is the key to keeping it running right.
Pros
- AWD is excellent traction in any weather
- Turbocharged options for the WRX and STI
- Reliable and designed for all-weather driving
Cons
- WRX and STI models will be expensive to run.
- Fuel mileage will be impacted in the performance models.
- Base Impreza could be more exciting.
How Do These Models Stack Up?
Now that we’ve broken down each car, it’s time to compare them directly:
Features | Mazdaspeed6 | Mazdaspeed3 | Subaru Impreza |
Horsepower | 274 hp | 263 hp | 268-310 hp |
Drive Type | AWD | FWD | AWD |
Transmission | 6-Speed Manual | 6-Speed Manual | 6-Speed Manual |
Practicality | Sedan design, roomy | Hatchback, flexible | Compact with good space |
Maintenance Cost | Higher, due to AWD | Moderate | Higher for WRX/STI |
Performance | Great all-weather | Quick, nimble | Best for all-weather |
Which Fits Your Needs?
- Opt for the Mazdaspeed6 if you like a stealthy, high-performance sedan with four-wheel drive. It is an excellent choice if you need a practical car but do not mind having some fun behind the driver’s seat.
- Opt for the Mazdaspeed3 if you are a hatchback fan who still craves that turbocharged thrill ride. It is a real value for the power it gives you, but be prepared to handle some torque steer.
- You choose the Subaru Impreza WRX or STI if you need a car built for all-weather performance and reliability. One of the WRX/STI models can give anyone enough power and grip to be great for those living in really harsh winters or for someone seeking the best AWD system out there.
Ultimately, The selection between the Mazdaspeed6, Mazdaspeed3, and Subaru Impreza WRX/STI depends on what you need from a sporty, affordable car. If it’s the best all-weather capability with solid power, the Mazdaspeed6 and the Subaru Impreza are good options. Or else, if you’d like a stealthy, performance-driven sedan experience, the Mazdaspeed6 is good, while if you want an authentic rally heritage and all-weather reliability, the Impreza WRX/STI is the best for you.
On the other hand, if you like being able to get into a hatchback and stomach a little torque steer, this Mazdaspeed3 is a pocket rocket that is practical and packed full of fun. Although each car is good in areas where the others are not so strong, all three will deliver on entertainment and driving without stealing all your cash.
Of course, in the final analysis, your choice will boil down to which one you need, but they all can go right—they’re a lot of bang for the buck.